| Player Tournament Awards | Players Name | Plays For | Stature | Tournament | Season | |
| All Tournament Team | Lonnie Wright | Team Mayhem | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | E World Qualifier | 2010 | |
| All Tournament Team | Jared Peters | Foul Ball Assassins | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 3rd Annual In It To Win It - Ohio USSSA Open NIT | 2013 | |
| All Tournament Team | Branden Petry | Gem City Mademen | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 3rd Annual In It To Win It - Ohio USSSA Open NIT | 2013 | |
| All Tournament Team | John Flynn | Gem City Mademen | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | E Laced Up | 2013 | |
| All Tournament Team | Branden Petry | Gem City Mademen | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | E Laced Up | 2013 | |
| All Tournament Team | Jordan Winkler | Total Chaos/ Red-Eye Sports | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | E Laced Up | 2013 | |
| All Tournament Team | Branden Petry | Mademen | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 2014 E For It All | 2014 | |
| Defensive Tournament MVP | Todd Finley | Red-Eye Sports/EFC/TF&G/PMI | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | Great Lakes Mixed Fall Classic | 2016 | |
| All Tournament Team | Branden Petry | Mademen | NIT - USSSA - Berth | 9th Annual Dayton Legends Mens | 2014 | |
| All Tournament Team | Branden Petry | Mademen | NIT - USSSA - Berth | USSSA D/E CASH BATTLE EQUALIZER | 2014 | |