| Player Tournament Awards | Players Name | Plays For | Stature | Tournament | Season | |
| All Tournament Team | Timothy Kiernan | C&M Transport / Nager Law / Lakes | Qualifier - GSL - Points | Miken Heroes Mission | 2020 | |
| All Tournament Team | John Scoarste | Four Star/ADCom/Buffalo Wild Wings | NIT - USSSA - Berth | Worth/Bud Light Men's D NIT | 2007 | |
| All Tournament Team | Timothy Kiernan | STL/Pepco/VSP/Wing Warehouse | GSL Super Dual NIT | Mojo Moneyball | 2018 | |
| All Tournament Team | John Scoarste | Four Star/ADCom/Buffalo Wild Wings | State - USSSA | Northern Ohio Men's Class D State | 2007 | |
| All Tournament Team | Paul Deutsch | WARPIG SOFTBALL | State - GSL | GSL D States - Northern OHIO | 2015 | |
| All Tournament Team | Kevin Jonke | WARPIG SOFTBALL | State - GSL | GSL D States - Northern OHIO | 2015 | |
| All Tournament Team | Andy Radcliffe | WARPIG SOFTBALL | State - GSL | GSL D States - Northern OHIO | 2015 | |
| All Tournament Team | Neil Taylor | C&M TRANSPORT/GREAT LAKES GUTTERS | State - GSL | Ohio State Tournament (Northern) | 2016 | |