| Player Tournament Awards | Players Name | Plays For | Stature | Tournament | Season | |
| Defensive Tournament MVP | Robert Crume | Highview Barber Softball Team | GSL Super Dual NIT | 20th Annual GSL Bash for Cash Super Dual | 2021 | |
| All Tournament Team | Ronald Schuur | Omen | State - GSL | GSL Indiana Tri-State Championships/Rings on Turf | 2026 | |
| Defensive Tournament MVP | Ronald Schuur | Omen | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 24th Annual Men's E City Slam | 2025 | |
| All Tournament Team | Ronald Schuur | Omen | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 24th Annual Men's E City Slam | 2025 | |
| All Tournament Team | Robert Crume | Highview Barber Softball | Qualifier - GSL - Points | PRIZE-A-PALOOZA | 2020 | |
| All Tournament Team | James Gregory | Omen | State - USSSA | USSSA STATE | 2020 | |
| All Tournament Team | David Breeden | Omen | State - Dual | ONE TRUE OHIO State Tournament | 2025 | |
| All Tournament Team | Robert Crume | Highview Barber Softball | World - USSSA | Men's D & E World Tournament | 2020 | |
| All Tournament Team | Ronald Schuur | Bone Jugs & Harmony | State - USSSA | co-ed state | 2012 | |