| Player Tournament Awards | Players Name | Plays For | Stature | Tournament | Season | |
| All Tournament Team | Josh Schramm | Blue Mountain/ Zides Sporting Goods | NIT - USSSA - Berth | Best of the West Men's C/D Upper NIT | 2014 | |
| All Tournament Team | Michael Riggins | Nature Boys / MSGA Sports | State - Dual | ONE TRUE OHIO State Tournament | 2025 | |
| All Tournament Team | Chase Phillips | Zanesville Eagles Aerie 302 | Regional - USSSA | Great Lakes Men's National | 2009 | |
| All Tournament Team | Michael Riggins | Hornets | World - GSL | GSL World Tournament - Midwest | 2023 | |
| All Tournament Team | Michael Riggins | Showtime | Qualifier - USSSA - Berth | 20th Annual USSSA Bash for Cash | 2021 | |
| All Tournament Team | Michael Riggins | Ohio | US Challenge Cup | USSSA Challenge Cup | 2022 | |
| All Tournament Team | MICHAEL ALLEN | Tyler Trucking | NIT - USSSA - Berth | Bryan Stevenson Memorial "Super" NIT | 2010 | |
| All Tournament Team | MICHAEL ALLEN | Tyler Trucking / Miken | NIT - USSSA - Berth | 10th Annual City Slam Men's Open NIT | 2011 | |