| Player Tournament Awards | Players Name | Plays For | Stature | Tournament | Season | |
| Home Run Club | Grayson Reynolds | KC Heat | Super NIT | CIS Line Drive Super NIT (AAA/Maj) 6/5-6/7 | 2026 | |
| All Tournament Team | Dylan McGraw | Central Florida Suns | USSSA NIT | BATMAN vs. JOKER NIT | 2025 | |
| Game MVP | Dylan McGraw | Central Florida Suns | USSSA NIT | BATMAN vs. JOKER NIT | 2025 | |
| Game MVP | Dylan McGraw | Peppermint Powerhouse | Individual Event | The Elf Games (Individual Player Event) | 2026 | |