| Player Tournament Awards | Players Name | Plays For | Stature | Tournament | Season | |
| All Tournament Team | Jon Berry | Buffet Boys | State - USSSA | USSSA STATE | 2021 | |
| All Tournament Team | Jeff Flood | Sixpac | State - GSL | GSL Indiana Tri-State Championships/Rings on Turf | 2023 | |
| All Tournament Team | Alex Hixenbaugh | Sixpac | State - GSL | GSL Indiana Tri-State Championships/Rings on Turf | 2023 | |
| All Tournament Team | steven House | DAZE/TPA WEAR | State - GSL | GSL OHIO STATE | 2026 | |
| Defensive Tournament MVP | Jon Berry | Sixpac | World - GSL | GSL World Tournament - Midwest | 2023 | |
| All Tournament Team | Alex Hixenbaugh | Sixpac | World - GSL | GSL World Tournament - Midwest | 2023 | |
| All Tournament Team | Jeff Flood | Creekers | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | Cols 'E' World Inv. | 2010 | |
| All Tournament Team | Jon Berry | HERITAGE ENGINEERING/PORTLAND | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | Border Wars | 2011 | |
| All Tournament Team | Steve Johnson | Ball Hawgs | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | Thorntons' Summer Slam | 2013 | |
| Tournament MVP | Michael Jones | Ball Hawgs | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | Legends 'E' WNIT | 2014 | |
| All Tournament Team | Brian Blackburn | Ball Hawgs | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | Legends 'E' WNIT | 2014 | |
| All Tournament Team | Michael Jones | Ball Hawgs | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | Legends 'E' WNIT | 2014 | |
| Defensive Tournament MVP | steven House | Six Pac | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | USSSA E Nationals | 2016 | |
| Defensive Tournament MVP | steven House | The Goonies | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | USSSA E Nationals | 2016 | |
| All Tournament Team | Jon Berry | HERITAGE ENGINEERING/PORTLAND | State - USSSA | KY State Tournament | 2011 | |
| Defensive Tournament MVP | Steve Johnson | Drunken Monkeys | State - USSSA | E State | 2012 | |
| Tournament MVP | Jeff Flood | Creekers | State - USSSA | E State | 2013 | |
| All Tournament Team | Jeff Flood | Creekers | State - USSSA | State Tournament | 2014 | |
| All Tournament Team | Jeff Flood | Creekers | Regional - USSSA | E Great Lakes Nationals | 2014 | |